advertisement
The Digital Divide Starts At The Till
Ben Cheick Haidara, Deputy CEO of Orange Africa and the Middle East, did not ask African governments for spectrum, subsidies or another regulator when he took the stage at the Africa Tech Festival on Tuesday. He asked them to stop taxing the phone in a young person’s pocket.
“I think they (African countries) should remove taxes on devices completely. Be it smartphones, be it computers,” Haidara said. “This is a unique opportunity for African people to be trained, to learn, to have access to sophisticated materials to improve their daily lives.”
The strongest evidence for his argument came from the country hosting him.
advertisement
On 1 April 2025, South Africa’s National Treasury removed the 9 per cent ad valorem excise duty on smartphones priced below $139, following the reclassification of handsets previously placed in the same tax bracket as luxury goods.
In its Mobile Economy Africa 2026 report, the GSMA, which represents mobile operators worldwide, documented the subsequent recovery in entry-level smartphone sales, the migration of feature-phone users to smartphones and increased 4G and 5G adoption. The industry body now cites South Africa’s policy change in its campaign for governments to remove taxes on devices costing less than $100.
Operators such as Orange stand to benefit directly when more people own smartphones, and the GSMA has made device taxation one of its central policy campaigns. But the figures it publishes help explain why the argument keeps returning.
advertisement
Roughly 63 per cent of Africans live within reach of a mobile broadband signal but do not use mobile internet, according to the report. Only 9 per cent live outside coverage altogether.
For most Africans who remain offline, the network is already there. What stands in the way is the cost of accessing it. An entry-level handset in sub-Saharan Africa costs an average of 24 per cent of monthly income, rising to as much as 80 per cent for the poorest users.
Deputy President Paul Mashatile, who opened the festival by video link from Pretoria, described the same divide in starker terms.
advertisement
“Millions of Africans still lack affordable and reliable access to broadband,” he said. “The cost of connectivity remains too high for many households, while cybersecurity threats continue to grow in scale and complexity. If left unaddressed, these challenges risk creating a two-speed Africa, one connected, innovative and prosperous, and another excluded from the opportunity of the digital age.”
Mashatile framed the solution as a continental undertaking.
“No African country will realise its digital potential in isolation,” he said.
He pointed to the African Continental Free Trade Area as a route towards a single digital market, with artificial intelligence helping to connect economies through seamless and secure payments.
The timing makes the handset question more pressing. Earlier this year, the GSMA warned that rising global memory prices were pushing up the cost of entry-level smartphones. It argued that reducing taxes and import duties on the cheapest devices had become more urgent.
Haidara’s second request went beyond the phone itself. He described education platforms through which teachers distribute learning materials and students “learn for free”, pointing to Mauritius as an example.
“Mauritius Telecom found it, and they paid for it. They understood that they should train their people so they could improve their lives,” he said.
“Imagine doing the same in other local languages, in Senegal, Burkina Faso, South Africa, Morocco … that all the governments decide to pay for that. If we train our people for free over 10 to 15 years, it will completely, I believe, transform Africa.”
Behind both speeches sits the same demographic reality. By 2050, according to the World Bank, a fifth of the world’s young people will live on the continent.
The festival opened as President Cyril Ramaphosa led a delegation through Silicon Valley, seeking to understand the AI economy and make South Africa’s case for investment. In Cape Town, his deputy put the challenge to fellow African leaders plainly.
“The question before us today is therefore not what our priorities are. We know them,” Mashatile said. “The real question is whether we are acting with the agency, ambition, partnership required to translate them into tangible benefit for Africa and its people.”
For governments weighing Haidara’s request, one answer is already on record in the customs schedule of the country where he made it.